Jennifer Love Hewitt Says She Hasn’t Spoken to Sarah Michelle Gellar in 28 Years — What Happened?
As the I Know What You Did Last Summer reboot made its star-studded debut in Los Angeles, fans of the original 1997 slasher hit were left with one burning question: Why didn’t Jennifer Love Hewitt and Sarah Michelle Gellar reunite on the red carpet?
Rumors of a long-standing feud between the two stars began swirling online after Gellar’s Instagram post from the event noticeably excluded any photos with Hewitt. But now, Hewitt is setting the record straight — and it’s not what you think.
Jennifer Love Hewitt: “We Haven’t Talked Since I Was 18”
In a new interview with Vulture published on July 18, Jennifer Love Hewitt directly addressed the speculation that she and Sarah Michelle Gellar had a falling out.
“I honestly don’t even know what that was or how that all came to be,” Hewitt said. “We’ve literally not talked since I was 18 years old when the first movie came out.”
Hewitt clarified that there is no feud, just a lack of communication over the past 28 years. “People love to pit women against each other,” she added. “Why do we always have to be out for each other?”
The Viral Instagram “Snub” Explained
Fueling the rumor mill was Sarah Michelle Gellar’s Instagram carousel from the I Know What You Did Last Summer premiere, where Jennifer Love Hewitt was absent from every frame.
Fans quickly jumped to conclusions — but Gellar responded directly in the comments:
“I never got to see @jenniferlovehewitt who is fantastic in the movie. I was inside with my kids while the red carpet photos were happening.”
She also revealed that Hewitt didn’t attend the cast afterparty, explaining the lack of interaction.
“If you’ve ever been to one of these, it’s crazy. Sadly, I didn’t get pics with most of the cast. But that doesn’t change how amazing I think they all are.”
28 Years Later: No Contact, No Drama
While it may surprise fans that these two iconic ‘90s stars haven’t spoken in nearly three decades, both women have emphasized that there’s no bad blood.
They simply haven’t stayed in touch — a reality that’s far more common in Hollywood than most people think.
Hewitt went on to have major success with shows like Ghost Whisperer and 9-1-1, while Gellar became a pop culture icon thanks to Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Cruel Intentions, and more recently, Wolf Pack.
Red Carpet Style: A Show-Stopping Contrast
Though they didn’t cross paths, both actresses stole the spotlight at the premiere:
- Jennifer Love Hewitt debuted a bold red hair transformation and rocked a black mirrored dress.
- Sarah Michelle Gellar turned heads in a purple butterfly-inspired 3D minidress and posed alongside husband and co-star Freddie Prinze Jr.
Their distinct looks and energy reminded fans why they’re both still fashion icons.
Why This Story Went Viral
- Nostalgia: Fans who grew up watching I Know What You Did Last Summer were eager to see a reunion.
- Social media misinterpretation: Gellar’s post sparked unnecessary drama that both actresses have calmly defused.
- Celebrity transparency: Hewitt’s honesty resonated with readers tired of tabloid-style headlines.
This blend of pop culture history and modern social dynamics is what made the story explode on platforms like Google Discover, X (formerly Twitter), and Reddit.
The Takeaway: No Feud, Just Life
Despite nearly three decades of silence, there’s no animosity between Jennifer Love Hewitt and Sarah Michelle Gellar. Life simply moved on — and so did they.
Both actresses continue to captivate fans, on-screen and off, and have handled the rumors with grace and clarity. If anything, this moment highlights the way social media can twist a simple truth into a viral misunderstanding.
So, no reunion selfie? No problem.
They’re both doing just fine — and still unforgettable.
Ready more
- Anne Hathaway Brings the Devil Back — and Fans Are Losing It
- HR Exec Kristin Cabot’s Viral Coldplay Moment Sends Shockwaves Through Boston’s High Society
- Golf Analyst Says c Might Surpass Tiger Woods — Fans React
- Manny Pacquiao Denied WBC Title in Controversial Draw Against Mario Barrios
- James Gunn Breaks Silence on Replacing Henry Cavill: “It Was Terrible”
